Insights · Doing the deal

How to negotiate buying a business: price, structure and stalled deals

The short answerNegotiate the whole deal, not just the headline price. Agree your walk-away points before you start, then settle the price mechanism, how and when the seller is paid, the protections you need and the seller's role after completion. Put the main terms and an exclusivity period in heads of terms, then let due diligence confirm or adjust them. Most stalled negotiations are not about price but about uncertainty, timing or the seller's feelings about what happens next.

Many founders approach their first acquisition as a price negotiation. In practice, the headline number is only one of several terms that decide what you actually pay, when you pay it and how much risk you carry. A higher price with the right structure can be a better deal than a lower price paid in full on day one.

This guide covers private company purchases in the UK, where the seller is usually the founder or a family.

Before you negotiate: set your limits

Write these down before the first conversation about price, and agree them with your board, co-owners or funder:

  • Your walk-away price, based on what the business is worth to you and what you can fund. Our guide to valuing a business before you buy it explains how to set it.
  • The risks you will not accept, such as a key customer who might leave or an unresolved legal claim.
  • What must be true for the deal to make sense: the profit level, the customers that stay, the people who stay.

These limits stop you drifting upward under pressure, and give you a clear reason to walk away.

What you are actually negotiating

TermWhy it matters to you
Headline priceUsually an enterprise value: the business on a cash-free, debt-free basis with a normal level of working capital.
Price mechanismLocked box or completion accounts. Decides how cash, debt and working capital change the final figure.
Payment structureCash at completion, deferred payments, an earn-out or a vendor loan note. Spreads cost and shares risk.
Warranties and indemnitiesThe seller's promises about the business, and who pays if they turn out to be wrong.
Seller's role after completionHow long they stay, in what role, and how customers and staff are introduced.
Restrictive covenantsStops the seller competing with you or taking customers and staff.
Exclusivity and timetableA period when the seller cannot talk to other buyers while you do your checks.

Locked box or completion accounts?

These are the two common ways of turning the agreed value into the price for the shares.

  • Completion accounts adjust the price after completion, based on the actual cash, debt and working capital on the day. They suit buyers who want the price to reflect the business as it is when they take over, and businesses whose accounts are less reliable.
  • Locked box fixes the price before exchange, using an agreed set of recent accounts. The seller promises not to take value out of the business (called leakage) between that date and completion. UK private deals often use it because it gives price certainty and avoids disputes after completion (Farrer & Co).

A locked box only works if you trust the accounts it is based on, so it raises the stakes on financial due diligence. In a 2018 sample of UK deals, 51.5% used completion accounts and 27% a locked box (TLT, 2018).

Using structure to bridge a price gap

When you and the seller disagree about value, the answer is often in how the price is paid rather than the number itself:

  • Deferred consideration: part of the price is paid later on fixed dates. It eases your cash flow and keeps the seller interested in a smooth handover.
  • Earn-out: part of the price is paid only if the business hits agreed targets after completion. It works where the seller is confident about growth you are not yet sure of. Define the targets and accounting rules precisely, because earn-outs are a common source of disputes.
  • Vendor loan note: the seller lends you part of the price, repaid with interest. If you also borrow from a bank, the bank will usually require the seller's loan to rank behind its own.

Our guide to funding an acquisition covers how these fit alongside bank borrowing.

What goes in heads of terms

Heads of terms (sometimes called a letter of intent) record the main commercial terms before lawyers draft the sale agreement. Most of their contents are not legally binding, apart from specific clauses such as exclusivity and confidentiality (RFB Legal). They should cover:

  • the price, the mechanism and the payment structure;
  • what is being bought (shares or assets) and any exclusions;
  • conditions, such as funding or regulatory approval;
  • the seller's role after completion and any restrictive covenants;
  • exclusivity, its length and the timetable;
  • who pays which costs.

Being specific here saves weeks later. Vague heads of terms mean every open point is renegotiated during the sale agreement, when both sides are tired and costs are mounting.

Why negotiations stall, and how to restart them

Deals rarely stall over price alone. Common causes, and what usually helps:

CauseWhat helps
The seller is not emotionally ready to let goTalk about what happens to the people, the name and their own role. Give them time, within a clear timetable.
Due diligence found somethingQuantify it. Then address it through price, a specific indemnity, a retention of part of the price, or a change in structure.
Different views of future profitUse an earn-out or deferred payment linked to the disputed part, not a lower headline price.
Advisers are negotiating points that do not matter to either sideOwners meet to agree the few commercial points that do, then instruct advisers.
Funding is not yet certainFirm up the funding before re-engaging. A seller loses confidence in a buyer who cannot show the money.

If a stall comes from breaching one of your written limits, and price or terms cannot fix it, that is your signal to walk away rather than restart.

Questions buyers ask

How do you negotiate the price when buying a business?

Start from what the business is worth to you and what you can fund, not from the asking price. Agree the headline value, then the mechanism (locked box or completion accounts) and the payment structure, because together they decide what you really pay. Use structure, such as deferred payments or an earn-out, to bridge gaps in value.

Are heads of terms legally binding?

Mostly not. Heads of terms record the agreed commercial principles, but are usually non-binding apart from specific clauses such as exclusivity, confidentiality and sometimes costs.

What is the difference between a locked box and completion accounts?

A locked box fixes the price before exchange based on agreed recent accounts, with the seller promising not to take value out before completion. Completion accounts adjust the price after completion based on the actual cash, debt and working capital on the day.

How long should exclusivity last?

Long enough to complete your due diligence and agree the sale agreement, often a few weeks to a few months depending on the size and complexity of the deal. Agree the length in heads of terms and keep to the timetable.

Already in talks?

We can value the business, shape the offer and run the deal from where it is now.

How we run a deal
Michael Ferguson
Michael Ferguson

Michael Ferguson is the founder of Acquisitiv and a Consultant at CDI Global in the United Kingdom. A chartered certified accountant (ACCA), he was head of M&A at a global, family-owned spirits group and finance director at a FTSE-listed company. He acts only for buyers. More about Michael

Read next

Thinking about buying a business?

Book a free 30-minute call. Afterwards, we send you a confidential brief on your market.

Book a free call